What Are Your Guys Nodding Along To?

Paywalls are the absolute worst, aren't they?

I'm sharing the article above with everyone knowing full well that when you click on it, you may be hit square in the face with a paywall restriction. But if that happens, have no fear, I have your takeaways and action steps here.

First of all, kudos to our colleagues at the Partnership for Male Youth for sending it to us this AM and sharing their analysis of author Jessica Grose's work. Second, the main takeaways for you stem not just from the election results (specifically how young men voted in the midterms), but from a statement about their online habits.

Yes, I see the significant swing among young male voters away from MAGA as a positive sign for those of us combating the manosphere. Yes, it was a good thing to see several candidates associated with that space take heavy losses, Russell Brand be sentenced for his crimes and the Tate brothers face criminal proceedings. All good things…but also not something any of us men get a cookie for, especially when you consider the continued contributions of women (particularly Black women) in opposing the politics of oppression.

But here is a sentence from Grose's analysis that I think could be the trigger for an impactful conversation in your team space this week:

“…That’s partly because Gen Z males tend to lurk rather than post, scattered across platforms like Rumble and Twitch…”

Why? Because the “lurk rather than post” part of that sentence is a doorway to a conversation about courage and standing in our own power.

LURKING, I take to mean scrolling, reading, passively digesting. That worries me because it's a way for our guys to take in harmful content without signaling to us, their parents or even their friends what they're being exposed to and whether they're buying into the language and teachings of those posts.

Most of our social media policies are likely to have accountability triggers for posting, liking or sharing. But those policies don't tell us much about what our guys are consuming when they're scrolling. And, to be clear, I'm not suggesting we should be monitoring that.

But I AM asking you to survey how they're using social media. Ask them to deploy their phone's built-in time trackers (which will show them minutes/hours spent on X or TikTok or IG). Tell them about apps like Brainrot, which I use myself to try and curb my own doomscrolling on socials.

And then ask them what it means to consume but not claim posts. In a good way, if I see something that promotes healthy manhood and positive community contribution, but I don't share it or even like it, what keeps me from publicly supporting something I privately believe in?

And on the flip side, if I read and nod along to the next post promoting harm, can I really say, “But that's not me, I didn't retweet it”?

Coach Prompts

How much of your understanding of your players' social media habits is based on what they POST versus what they actually CONSUME? Have you ever asked them about the difference?

When was the last time you examined your own screen time and the types of content you regularly consume? What might your own scrolling habits reveal about the ideas you're reinforcing in yourself?

How can you create a conversation about the content your players consume without making them feel like you're asking to police their phones?

Player Prompts

Agree, Disagree or Unsure: I can consume content that promotes harmful ideas about women and manhood without it influencing the way I think or behave.

Have you ever seen a post you agreed with but chose not to like or share because you were worried about how your boys might react? What does that tell you about the power your friends have over what you're willing to publicly support?

Open your phone's screen time tracker and examine how much time you've spent on social media over the past seven days. What percentage of that time do you think was spent consuming content that actually helped you become the person you want to be?

Next
Next

Have You Taught Them HOW to Calm Down?